New Listing - 05/21/2025

$2,350,000 ($416.22 per sqft)

Est. Mortgage $12,194/mo *

Quick Pre-Approval

Brochure

Call Text Schedule Tour Request More Information

Open House Schedule

05/22/2025
12:00 PM to 2:00 PM
Google calendar
Other calendars

35 S Penataquit Avenue, Brightwaters, (Bay Shore), NY, 11706

35 S Penataquit Avenue, Brightwaters, (Bay Shore), NY, 11706
View larger map Directions

18 rooms

9 beds

4 Full / 1 Half baths

1890

Other

5,646 sqft

Step into timeless elegance with this stately 9 bedroom 4.5 bath Federal Style home encompassing over 5,646 square feet of living space. Built in 1890, this grand home is steeped in rich history- once owned by George Macy, the famed tea importer. This architectural gem showcases classic period details including four working fireplaces, intricate woodwork and moldings, high ceilings, and generously proportioned rooms. The gracious formal living and dining room are ideal for inside entertaining, while a specious deck allows for fabulous outdoor entertaining. This home sits on an expansive 1.4 acre lot and includes a 3-car detached garage, mature landscaping, and a commanding presence that reflects its storied past. With nine spacious bedrooms and four and a half baths, this is a rare opportunity to own a piece of history in an area known for it's prestigious homes and legacy properties.

Status:

Active

Town:

Brightwaters

Type:

Single-family residential

Garage:

3-car

Cooling:

Ductless, Wall/Window Unit(s)

Basement:

Full, Partially Finished

Acreage:

1.4

Est. Taxes:

$25,396

Assessment

$77,900

Construction

Cedar

Utilities

Natural Gas Connected

Elementary School:

Brook Avenue Elementary School

Middle School:

Bay Shore Middle School

High School:

Bay Shore Senior High School

School District:

Bay Shore

Appliances:

Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Electric Oven, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Trash Compactor, Washer, Gas Water Heater, Wine Refrigerator

MLS #:

847363

Community Info

School Info

Walk Score

Mass Transit

Yelp

Similar Properties

$2,195,000

3 beds

2 baths

2,200 sqft

30 Sagg Road, Sagaponack, NY, 11962

Price Reduced!

$2,500,000

5 beds

4.5 baths

4,200 sqft

3 Farrington Road, Montauk, NY, 11954

$2,250,000

4 beds

4.5 baths

3,600 sqft

103 MIDDLE POND RD, Southampton, NY, 11968

Price Reduced!

$2,300,000

3 beds

2.5 baths

1,200 sqft

14 Hamilton Street, Sag Harbor, NY, 11963

$2,199,999

5 beds

4.5 baths

4,800 sqft

10 Green Knoll Court, Northport, NY, 11768

$2,200,000

3 beds

1.5 baths

1,200 sqft

Bridgehampton, NY, 11932

Price Reduced!

$2,200,000

5 beds

2.5 baths

5,575 sqft

9 Porpoise Court, Northport, NY, 11768

$2,495,000

4 beds

2.5 baths

42 Davis Drive, Montauk, NY, 11954

$2,340,000

5 beds

3 baths

3,150 sqft

77 Front Street, Riverhead, (South Jamesport), NY, 11970

$2,499,000

3 beds

3 baths

1,571 sqft

105 Lockitt Drive, Riverhead, (Jamesport), NY, 11947

$2,499,000

6 beds

6.5 baths

6,700 sqft

140 Daly Road, Northport, (East Northport), NY, 11731

Price Reduced!

$2,150,000

4 beds

2.5 baths

2,700 sqft

55 Seacove Lane, Riverhead, (Jamesport), NY, 11947

$2,550,000

3 beds

1.5 baths

1,565 sqft

1521 Peconic Bay Boulevard, Riverhead, (Laurel), NY, 11948

$2,400,000

4 beds

3 baths

1,859 sqft

329 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach, NY, 11770

$2,399,000

7 beds

3 baths

2,700 sqft

107 Jessup Avenue, Quogue, NY, 11959

Price Reduced!

$2,155,000

4 beds

2 baths

1,800 sqft

6 Laurel Drive, Montauk, NY, 11954

New or Coming Soon Properties

New Listing!

$2,495,000

3 beds

2 baths

1,614 sqft

107 Seven Ponds Road, Southampton, (Water Mill), NY, 11976

$2,395,000

4 beds

3.5 baths

2,900 sqft

33 Lagoon Court, Riverhead, (Jamesport), NY, 11901

New Listing!

$2,370,000

4 beds

3 baths

2,666 sqft

50 Depot Road, Westhampton Beach, NY, 11978

New Listing!

$2,300,000

3 beds

2 baths

1,500 sqft

545 Glen Court, Southold, (Cutchogue), NY, 11935

New Listing!

$2,225,000

4 beds

3 baths

2,422 sqft

4 Shore Road, Bellport, (Bellport Village), NY, 11713

New Listing!

$2,295,000

5 beds

3 baths

4,575 sqft

10 Spinnaker Court, Huntington, (Northport), NY, 11768

New Listing!

$2,349,000

6 beds

6 baths

5,300 sqft

10 Colonial Drive, Smithtown, NY, 11787

New Listing!

$2,350,000

4 beds

4 baths

2,900 sqft

35 Club Drive, Riverhead, (Baiting Hollow), NY, 11933

New Listing!

$2,475,000

4 beds

3 baths

2,877 sqft

46 Tuthill Point Road, Brookhaven, (East Moriches), NY, 11940

New Listing!

$2,550,000

5 beds

4.5 baths

3,500 sqft

2455 New Suffolk Avenue, Southold, (Mattituck), NY, 11952

New Listing!

$2,195,000

4 beds

2.5 baths

3,234 sqft

5850 New Suffolk Road, Southold, (New Suffolk), NY, 11956

New Listing!

$2,499,000

5 beds

3 baths

2,300 sqft

900 Dune Road, Southampton, (Westhampton Beach), NY, 11978

New Listing!

$2,283,000

5 beds

3.5 baths

2,723 sqft

12 Sunset Path, Brookhaven, (Port Jefferson), NY, 11777

New Listing!

$2,300,000

5 beds

4.5 baths

4,300 sqft

1 Briar Court, Huntington, (Melville), NY, 11747

New Listing!

$2,350,000

5 beds

4.5 baths

4,300 sqft

9 Hill & Tree Court, Huntington, (Melville), NY, 11747

New Listing!

$2,295,000

3 beds

3 baths

2,500 sqft

2300 Glenn Road, Southold, NY, 11971


Listing courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty 631-647-7013