New Listing - 05/17/2025
4 Bayview Avenue, Shelter Island, (Shelter Island Heights), NY, 11965
12 rooms
6 beds
5 Full / 1 Half baths
2003
Colonial
5,000 sqft
Introducing 4 Bay View Ave Shelter Island Heights A beautiful 6 Bedroom 6 Bath residence nestled in the heart of historic Shelter Island Heights. A home designed for meaningful moments, effortless entertaining, and everyday comfort. Brand new kitchen with Monogram appliances. Six spacious bedrooms and five and a half baths, this elegant property offers room to grow, gather, and recharge. From the moment you walk in, you’ll find beautifully appointed sitting areas that invite conversation, connection, or a quiet cup of tea with a good book. The fully finished lower level flows seamlessly to the pool and backyard, creating a perfect blend of indoor and outdoor living. Whether you’re hosting summer soiree enjoying a peaceful weekend with family, this home adapts to your every mood. Enjoy thoughtful touches throughout, including central air, a cozy fireplace for chilly evenings, and a dedicated office space that supports both productivity and peace of mind. A separate guest quarters ensures everyone has the space they need—and you have the privacy you deserve. Surrounded by mature trees and lush landscaping, the property is a private sanctuary. The expansive mahogany decks on both the main and guest houses are made for alfresco dining, stargazing, or sunset cocktails with friends. Indulge in the coastal lifestyle with access to a community beach club and tennis courts, or unwind in the heated gunite pool after a day in the sun. An outdoor shower adds a refreshing, spa-like touch. The radiant-heated two-car garage offers year-round comfort and convenience, and there’s even room for your own tennis court—because your home should reflect your passions. With over 5,000 square feet of thoughtfully designed space, this is more than a home—it’s a haven
Status:
Active
Town:
Shelter Island
Type:
Single-family residential
Garage:
2-car
Heating:
Hot Water, Radiant Floor
Cooling:
Central Air
Basement:
Finished, Walk-Out Access
Common Charge:
$9,200 Annually
Acreage:
0.92
Est. Taxes:
$11,000
HOA Fee
$9,200
Utilities
Electricity Connected
Amenities:
Playground, Tennis Court(s)
Elementary School:
Contact Agent
Middle School:
Contact Agent
High School:
Contact Agent
School District:
Shelter Island
Appliances:
Dishwasher, Dryer, Exhaust Fan, Microwave, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer
Pool:
In Ground
MLS #:
863707
Community Info
School Info
Walk Score
Mass Transit
Yelp
Similar Properties
New or Coming Soon Properties
Listing courtesy of Joseph W Johns 516-456-6001